Drove a 9th Si back to back with a 10th EX-T

[Roddy]

Hi Guys,

I watched the video posted by Hondata comparing the 10th Gen EX-T to a 9th Gen Si... I was a little skeptical... I'd like to see a run from a dead stop and from lower speeds, which no one has posted

So I decided to try each one for myself. The 9th Si is FUN, its engaging, I SO Enjoyed driving it. The 10th EX-T is plush, smooth, modern tech galore! It has linear power, which is expected with the turbo.... The only time the 10th felt faster was right around 70mph it just pushes hard it made me say "Oh WOW..thats quick right there"...and then it kind of tapered off....

IMO the 9th Si is the quicker, sportier car, WAY more engaging.... I didnt want to take it back... the 10th was "sleepy"...nice power... and I think from a 50mph roll it might be quicker than a stock 9th Si due to the infinite gearing of the CVT... but from a dig, lower speed roll and a run to mid triple digits... I'd say 9th Si....

Fun factor = 9th Si for sure

With no Si for 2016 and me needing a new car ASAP I will likely buy a used 9th Si

Sponsored

 

[instroke]

Good to hear - I am also thinking of buying a used or last of the 15 si's. The 16 Sedan looks fine but the 16 coupe looks rough.

 

[Design]

With no Si for 2016

I wouldn't rule it out just yet...

 

[gtman]

I wouldn't rule it out just yet...

It's definitely coming out as a 2017 and should hopefully be released in late fall this year.

 

[hunter44102]

Just remember you will spend about 30 to 40% more money on gas on a 9th gen Civic SI. 31MPG vs 42MPG highway, and 22MPG vs 32MPG city. Of course prices are low right now so not as big of a deal.

 

[Phosky]

I'd get a VW GTI instead of the 9th gen Si. I currently have a 9th gen Si as a daily driver, and it's quick enough up to legal speed limits, but it just doesn't feel like it pulls on the highway. The video of the 10th gen EX-T vs 9th gen Si really confirmed my initial feeling (ie. it wasn't just because I was used to my turbo 98 Civic hatch).

 

[Design]

They are good up to 60-70K. Pretty much a maintenance pit after 100-120K.

 

[instroke]

Hey Roddy - when you did the comparison - did you have a manual 16 or auto?

 

[optikalillusi0n]

They are good up to 60-70K. Pretty much a maintenance pit after 100-120K.

Are you referring to the 9th Gen Si or the GTI?

 

[Roddy]

apples to apples... ie a 2012 si compared to a 2012 GTI pricewise the Si is thousands cheaper in my area.

Hey Roddy - when you did the comparison - did you have a manual 16 or auto?

There are only CVT automatics available right now with the 1.5T

 

[bowler13joe]

Just remember you will spend about 30 to 40% more money on gas on a 9th gen Civic SI. 31MPG vs 42MPG highway, and 22MPG vs 32MPG city. Of course prices are low right now so not as big of a deal.

I don't necessarily agree with this. I drive a 2013 SI Sedan and I get about 26-28 in the city and 36+ on the highway. I also don't have a lead foot haha. It does take premium gas, though (91+).

 

[jk147]

I mean it is just me and I own a Civic as well. But there are a lot more options in 2016 than the 9th gen Civic Si. Especially when we are venturing into the newish used market for a sporty compact.

Sponsored