davemarco
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jun 3, 2017
- Threads
- 148
- Messages
- 2,638
- Reaction score
- 1,458
- Location
- SoCal
- Vehicle(s)
- 2019 Civic Type R (CBP), 2013 Audi TTRS
- Thread starter
- #1
Hi all - long time lurker, first time poster here. I've been eagerly awaiting the opportunity to test drive the 10th Gen SI since it was announced last year, and yesterday, I finally got my chance. I've been rocking a combo of a 2007 Nissan Sentra for daily commuting, and a 2001 Honda Prelude (5th Gen) for weekend fun. My primary goal in test driving to was to compare the SI's performance to my Prelude's for driving fun, and to evaluate it's comfort/convenience against my Sentra's for commuting.
With this in mind, I hopped in the Prelude and took a spirited, 30 minute jaunt over to the Honda dealer to see how the SI stacks up.
Power
As I pulled out of the dealership in Sport Mode, I immediately noticed how much more low and mid range power the 1.5L Turbo in the new SI has. When I'm in my Prelude, I have to accelerate full throttle in first to really pull away from a dead stop with any haste (VTEC doesn't kick in until ~6500 RPM). Not so with the new SI. The car began picking up speed fairly quickly from a dead stop, and once the boost kicked in (~3500 RPM), the car really started to move. It put a huge smile on my face to feel so much power so early in the band. It didn't necessarily push me back in my seat like the 2017 WRX did, but the SI did feel much lighter than that car when accelerating. As someone who enjoys spirited driving on the street, but has no desire to track the car, I felt like the power was "enough".
The one big negative that did bug me a lot was the turbo lag. While cruising along in the SI, I suddenly stomped down on the accelerator. With my Prelude, this would have resulted in a jarring, neck snapping sudden acceleration -- not because of any great power in the Prelude, but because of its instant throttle response. I can rapidly tap the Prelude's gas pedal and be treated to a rapid staccato of tiny accelerations. In the SI, stomping on the accelerator got me zero response -- nothing. As I held the petal down in disbelief, the boost slowly built up over 2-3 seconds, and then the car suddenly and quickly began accelerating forward.
I believe that over in the tuning boards here, this was identified as an artificial boost lag known as Boost Target Dampening -- a system where the turbo artificially spools up at a constant rate until it meets a target pressure set by the throttle position. I never knew how terrible this feeling was. It occurred not just when stomping down while cruising at low RPM's; the same lag was there when suddenly downshifting and attempting to accelerate as well. It was pronounced enough that I could see it becoming a safety issue in certain circumstances. I will say upfront that this is my only major gripe about the car, but it was bad enough to make me second guess my decision to buy. I know that KTuner and Hondata have begun releasing fixes for this, but from what I've read, the general consensus is that these fixes make the car jarring to drive in traffic. I will be eagerly monitoring those threads for updates on this.
Handling and Feel
With its incredibly low stance (even stock), stiff suspension, and hydraulic power steering, I expected the Prelude to win this one handily. Imagine my surprise when I discovered that this was not the case. Just to be clear, even in Sport Mode, the electronic power steering in the SI is still far less communicative than the old-school system in the Prelude. What really impressed me about the SI though, was how little body roll there was in tight turns. In the Prelude, I experience a modest amount of roll -- this causes me to generally adhere to the old slow in/fast out philosophy. While in SI's Sport Mode, I decided to throw this caution to the wind. During my test drive, I attacked several blind hairpins at way faster speeds than I should've (per my comfort with my Prelude's suspension). The results were shocking -- the SI refused to roll at all. I began to get more and more aggressive, and it proceeded to cling to every line with a neutral death grip. I never once felt that I was at the limits of grip (likely aided by the summer performance tires as well). I would say that the money that Honda invested in upgrading the suspension really paid off here. I would go so far as to say that this was the most impressive thing about the car for me.
The actual comfort level of the suspension was also surprisingly high. While I'm sure that it comes at a trade-off to road feedback, the ride was way smoother than the Prelude. I would say that it could definitely replace my Sentra as a daily driver, though I do imagine that on some of my short, spirited weekend jaunts, I would miss the exciting feeling that comes from the super stiff, "connected to the road" feeling of the Prelude's suspension. I just won't miss the skull jarring feeling of going over broken pavement and potholes in that car.
The stance of the car is (as expected) somewhat higher than the Prelude. Short of the BRZ/86, I have never driven a car in which you sit as low as you do in the Prelude stock. If I get an SI, I will likely have my eye on those HFP lowering springs that I've been reading about.
With regards to the Si's shifter, I will be blunt -- the shift action is extremely smooth, with no trace of friction or "notchy-ness". That said, I despise the actual shift knob itself. This thing is tiny - and I mean TINY. It's like it was designed by a toddler. Instead of gripping the shifter and energetically ripping shifts like I do in my Prelude, I felt like I had to delicately hold the tiny globe in the SI between three fingers and gently lean it back and forth. Not a fan at all.
I also just want to briefly touch on the clutch. I know that most reviewers mentioned this, but I was still shocked by how light it was. I always felt that my Prelude's clutch had a "medium" level stiffness to it, but that it wasn't particularly stiff. After test driving the SI, shifting while driving home in the Prelude felt like I was performing leg presses in deep quick sand. Personally, I really liked the lighter feel of the SI's clutch, and could see it making it a breeze to drive the car in heavy stop and go traffic.
Fit and Finish
Love it or hate it, we've all been through this by now. The Prelude was nice for its day, but the interior is now extremely dated. The SI's interior is surprisingly nice. I actually find that I really like the tablet-esque touch screen head unit. The red dash is also surprisingly nice. I'm generally a big fan of analog gauges (love the white gauges on the new 2018 WRX), but the electronic dash readout on the SI was surprisingly big and easy to read. It also seems to refresh fairly quickly.
The actual dash materials were much nicer than I had expected. The carbon-fiber trim, which I had expected to look like gaudy, shiny plastic (like on some of the more recent WRX models) was surprisingly muted and nice. It had a decidedly matte appearance, and did not look gaudy at all.
I will say that I am not a fan of the cheap look to the "leather-wrapped" steering wheel. The Prelude, like many late 90's/early 2000's era cars of it's class, came with a very nice, dark leather wrapped steering wheel. By comparison, the leather-wrapped steering wheel on the SI (and some other new cars of it's class) looks more like gray plastic to me.
The "premium" stereo came through loud and clear with no detectable distortion even at high volume. That said, the sound was very flat, with almost no bass whatsoever. It's acceptable enough not to disqualify the car, but I will definitely be looking into upgrades in the future should I get it. For comparison -- the Harmon Kardon system in the Limited WRX, while by no means a powerhouse, sounded much punchier and stronger with both systems set to a neutral EQ.
The seats were a huge high point for me in the SI. I was surprised by how well bolstered they were - very comfortable with great support. That said, I'm 5'5" and ~147 lbs, so I could imagine that a plus-sized individual might have some difficulty fitting comfortably.
Conclusion
Overall, I was very impressed with the car. It checks way more boxes than I thought it would -- particularly in light of its very affordable price tag. I could pay a couple thousand more for a Base WRX, but with none of the technology and creature comforts that I need in a car that doubles as a daily commuter. The price for a comparably specc-ed WRX? ~$31,000 - and that's at invoice pricing!
The power and handling in the SI were very nice - it won't be winning any races against it's closest competitors (WRX, GTI, etc.), but for those out there that prefer to enjoy some spirited weekend driving (dive-bombing some off ramps and powering around some back roads) it won't disappoint.
I would say that if a tuning option is made available that removes that artificial lag in a way that is not too jarring (responsiveness should still be proportionate to the throttle input), then this car will be the perfect little sport coupe for the weekend enthusiast. Until then, I will be patiently waiting for a good deal on a white or black coupe in the Upstate NY area.
With this in mind, I hopped in the Prelude and took a spirited, 30 minute jaunt over to the Honda dealer to see how the SI stacks up.
Power
As I pulled out of the dealership in Sport Mode, I immediately noticed how much more low and mid range power the 1.5L Turbo in the new SI has. When I'm in my Prelude, I have to accelerate full throttle in first to really pull away from a dead stop with any haste (VTEC doesn't kick in until ~6500 RPM). Not so with the new SI. The car began picking up speed fairly quickly from a dead stop, and once the boost kicked in (~3500 RPM), the car really started to move. It put a huge smile on my face to feel so much power so early in the band. It didn't necessarily push me back in my seat like the 2017 WRX did, but the SI did feel much lighter than that car when accelerating. As someone who enjoys spirited driving on the street, but has no desire to track the car, I felt like the power was "enough".
The one big negative that did bug me a lot was the turbo lag. While cruising along in the SI, I suddenly stomped down on the accelerator. With my Prelude, this would have resulted in a jarring, neck snapping sudden acceleration -- not because of any great power in the Prelude, but because of its instant throttle response. I can rapidly tap the Prelude's gas pedal and be treated to a rapid staccato of tiny accelerations. In the SI, stomping on the accelerator got me zero response -- nothing. As I held the petal down in disbelief, the boost slowly built up over 2-3 seconds, and then the car suddenly and quickly began accelerating forward.
I believe that over in the tuning boards here, this was identified as an artificial boost lag known as Boost Target Dampening -- a system where the turbo artificially spools up at a constant rate until it meets a target pressure set by the throttle position. I never knew how terrible this feeling was. It occurred not just when stomping down while cruising at low RPM's; the same lag was there when suddenly downshifting and attempting to accelerate as well. It was pronounced enough that I could see it becoming a safety issue in certain circumstances. I will say upfront that this is my only major gripe about the car, but it was bad enough to make me second guess my decision to buy. I know that KTuner and Hondata have begun releasing fixes for this, but from what I've read, the general consensus is that these fixes make the car jarring to drive in traffic. I will be eagerly monitoring those threads for updates on this.
Handling and Feel
With its incredibly low stance (even stock), stiff suspension, and hydraulic power steering, I expected the Prelude to win this one handily. Imagine my surprise when I discovered that this was not the case. Just to be clear, even in Sport Mode, the electronic power steering in the SI is still far less communicative than the old-school system in the Prelude. What really impressed me about the SI though, was how little body roll there was in tight turns. In the Prelude, I experience a modest amount of roll -- this causes me to generally adhere to the old slow in/fast out philosophy. While in SI's Sport Mode, I decided to throw this caution to the wind. During my test drive, I attacked several blind hairpins at way faster speeds than I should've (per my comfort with my Prelude's suspension). The results were shocking -- the SI refused to roll at all. I began to get more and more aggressive, and it proceeded to cling to every line with a neutral death grip. I never once felt that I was at the limits of grip (likely aided by the summer performance tires as well). I would say that the money that Honda invested in upgrading the suspension really paid off here. I would go so far as to say that this was the most impressive thing about the car for me.
The actual comfort level of the suspension was also surprisingly high. While I'm sure that it comes at a trade-off to road feedback, the ride was way smoother than the Prelude. I would say that it could definitely replace my Sentra as a daily driver, though I do imagine that on some of my short, spirited weekend jaunts, I would miss the exciting feeling that comes from the super stiff, "connected to the road" feeling of the Prelude's suspension. I just won't miss the skull jarring feeling of going over broken pavement and potholes in that car.
The stance of the car is (as expected) somewhat higher than the Prelude. Short of the BRZ/86, I have never driven a car in which you sit as low as you do in the Prelude stock. If I get an SI, I will likely have my eye on those HFP lowering springs that I've been reading about.
With regards to the Si's shifter, I will be blunt -- the shift action is extremely smooth, with no trace of friction or "notchy-ness". That said, I despise the actual shift knob itself. This thing is tiny - and I mean TINY. It's like it was designed by a toddler. Instead of gripping the shifter and energetically ripping shifts like I do in my Prelude, I felt like I had to delicately hold the tiny globe in the SI between three fingers and gently lean it back and forth. Not a fan at all.
I also just want to briefly touch on the clutch. I know that most reviewers mentioned this, but I was still shocked by how light it was. I always felt that my Prelude's clutch had a "medium" level stiffness to it, but that it wasn't particularly stiff. After test driving the SI, shifting while driving home in the Prelude felt like I was performing leg presses in deep quick sand. Personally, I really liked the lighter feel of the SI's clutch, and could see it making it a breeze to drive the car in heavy stop and go traffic.
Fit and Finish
Love it or hate it, we've all been through this by now. The Prelude was nice for its day, but the interior is now extremely dated. The SI's interior is surprisingly nice. I actually find that I really like the tablet-esque touch screen head unit. The red dash is also surprisingly nice. I'm generally a big fan of analog gauges (love the white gauges on the new 2018 WRX), but the electronic dash readout on the SI was surprisingly big and easy to read. It also seems to refresh fairly quickly.
The actual dash materials were much nicer than I had expected. The carbon-fiber trim, which I had expected to look like gaudy, shiny plastic (like on some of the more recent WRX models) was surprisingly muted and nice. It had a decidedly matte appearance, and did not look gaudy at all.
I will say that I am not a fan of the cheap look to the "leather-wrapped" steering wheel. The Prelude, like many late 90's/early 2000's era cars of it's class, came with a very nice, dark leather wrapped steering wheel. By comparison, the leather-wrapped steering wheel on the SI (and some other new cars of it's class) looks more like gray plastic to me.
The "premium" stereo came through loud and clear with no detectable distortion even at high volume. That said, the sound was very flat, with almost no bass whatsoever. It's acceptable enough not to disqualify the car, but I will definitely be looking into upgrades in the future should I get it. For comparison -- the Harmon Kardon system in the Limited WRX, while by no means a powerhouse, sounded much punchier and stronger with both systems set to a neutral EQ.
The seats were a huge high point for me in the SI. I was surprised by how well bolstered they were - very comfortable with great support. That said, I'm 5'5" and ~147 lbs, so I could imagine that a plus-sized individual might have some difficulty fitting comfortably.
Conclusion
Overall, I was very impressed with the car. It checks way more boxes than I thought it would -- particularly in light of its very affordable price tag. I could pay a couple thousand more for a Base WRX, but with none of the technology and creature comforts that I need in a car that doubles as a daily commuter. The price for a comparably specc-ed WRX? ~$31,000 - and that's at invoice pricing!
The power and handling in the SI were very nice - it won't be winning any races against it's closest competitors (WRX, GTI, etc.), but for those out there that prefer to enjoy some spirited weekend driving (dive-bombing some off ramps and powering around some back roads) it won't disappoint.
I would say that if a tuning option is made available that removes that artificial lag in a way that is not too jarring (responsiveness should still be proportionate to the throttle input), then this car will be the perfect little sport coupe for the weekend enthusiast. Until then, I will be patiently waiting for a good deal on a white or black coupe in the Upstate NY area.
Sponsored
Last edited: