Civic Type R Takes 3rd in 2018 Road & Track Performance Car of the Year

administrator

Administrator
First Name
Admin
Joined
Apr 1, 2015
Threads
343
Messages
877
Reaction score
2,353
Location
CivicX.com
Vehicle(s)
Honda
Build Thread
Link
Country flag
Honda Civic 10th gen Civic Type R Takes 3rd in 2018 Road & Track Performance Car of the Year top-ext-1509634472


Great showing for the Civic Type R in this year's 2018 Road & Track Performance Car of the Year competition!

Full competition results: http://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/a13132962/2018-performance-car-of-the-year/

It’d be a lie to say that no one missed the old company vibe, the spirit of the Integra and the S2000. But good Lord, does the Type R hustle. And above all, it shares one thing with the cars of the old-school Big H: Calm and comfortable when you’re cruising, a firecracker when you lean into it. The taillights wag on trailed brake, and the Civic will launch over track curbs or road chuckholes with your foot to the floor, the helical limited-slip clawing away, the car not even remotely slowing down. Topping it all off, no Civic ever had a brake pedal this communicative or effective—the enormous Brembo calipers behind the front wheels virtually evaporate speed.

Alone in this group, the Honda begs you to get angry. But it’s also a fully finished piece, capable and resolved at once. “Magic,” Wolfkill said, “and the handling is standout.” Okulski was shocked: “No torque steer. How?”

You forgive the styling, that obnoxious wing, the gaudy interior. The Honda wants to be hammered on for days, and unlike with the Alfa or the Audi, you’re thrilled to comply. —Sam Smith


THE FINALISTS

And then there were four—the Chevrolet Camaro ZL1 1LE, Honda Civic Type R, Lexus LC 500, and McLaren 720S. You’d be hard-pressed to choose a broader-spectrum anti-biotic for creeping automotive disinterest, yet at the core, each of these cars expresses a similarly uncompromising approach to performance-focused engineering. They’re loaded with things that you only notice after long examination: the heavy-duty steering knuckles on the Civic, the combination knob/switch used by the Lexus to adjust the shocks and relax the stability control, the knee bolstering on the Camaro’s center console, the way the TFT dashboard on the McLaren Fosbury-flops out of the way for unimpeded vision on a racetrack. You can have opinions about the Civic’s aero package or the McLaren’s socketed headlamps, but you can’t say that our final four don’t bring their A game in nearly every aspect that matters to a driver.

In years past, the PCOTY voting process has taken as long as four hours, often laced with impassioned speeches, tense disagreements, and uncomfortable bouts of soul-searching. Not this time. A single round of discussion and voting took a fraction of that. Our eight editors each assigned a ranking to the finalists. The rankings were added and averaged to provide the final results. Only two cars received first-place votes, and the mathematical distance between each place turned out to be unequivocal.

The third spot goes to the Civic Type R. Let’s get the low points out of the way in a hurry: The engine rarely feels fast and never comes across as particularly furious, the steering can seem inert, and the visual package is, shall we say, controversial. Chilton was properly cutting: “Even if it was quicker than the AMG, I couldn’t forgive those fake bumper grilles.”

None of those problems will stop the Type R from sporting additional-dealer-markup stickers for some time to come, however, because this is a Honda truly worthy of the coveted red badge.

In a market segment where some competitors are gelded by crossover-grade all-wheel drive and a ’77 Cutlass Supreme’s worth of curb weight, the Civic shines despite, and by virtue of, its fealty to the original hot-hatch template. “It possesses the unique ability to be driven like a front-wheel-drive car when it’s convenient—back it into turns under trail braking to get it rotated—without suffering from typical front-drive hang-ups under acceleration,” said Wolfkill. And the almost cosplay-like dedication to Nineties Ginza chic, while not everyone’s taste, will create a lot of fanatics and inspire plenty of tattoos. Most important, it’s a reminder that Honda still cares about its enthusiast owners.

Honda Civic 10th gen Civic Type R Takes 3rd in 2018 Road & Track Performance Car of the Year roa120117fea-pcoty-burnett-03-1509568468
Honda Civic 10th gen Civic Type R Takes 3rd in 2018 Road & Track Performance Car of the Year roa120117fea-pcoty-burnett-12-1509563921

Honda Civic 10th gen Civic Type R Takes 3rd in 2018 Road & Track Performance Car of the Year roa120117fea-pcoty-pardon-36-1509570258

Honda Civic 10th gen Civic Type R Takes 3rd in 2018 Road & Track Performance Car of the Year roa120117fea-pcoty-pardon-10-1509571247
Honda Civic 10th gen Civic Type R Takes 3rd in 2018 Road & Track Performance Car of the Year roa120117fea-pcoty-pardon-24-1509565011
 

ClemsonPatriot

Senior Member
First Name
Kyle
Joined
Jul 11, 2017
Threads
7
Messages
168
Reaction score
123
Location
South Carolina
Vehicle(s)
2017 Honda Civic Si Sedan
Vehicle Showcase
1
Country flag
That is a 1st place win for Honda in my book! I wonder by Ford or VW didn't enter in the RS or GTI, respectively? Think it has anything to do with reliability issues?
 


taiso0019

Senior Member
First Name
David
Joined
Jun 21, 2017
Threads
2
Messages
165
Reaction score
158
Location
Charlotte
Vehicle(s)
2017 CTR | 2022 Veloster N | 2015 TuRD PRO
Country flag
That is a 1st place win for Honda in my book! I wonder by Ford or VW didn't enter in the RS or GTI, respectively? Think it has anything to do with reliability issues?
Not really how the comparison works. They take any newly released cars for the calendar year and then pick a winner from that bunch. The Golf R and RS would have been in previous years' comparisons...but looking back at the last few they didn't even get a mention.

I'd chalk it up to either lack of availability/scheduling or they didn't make enough of an impression for R&T staff(doubtful). Something to note is that the last time there were any sport compacts was back in the 2015 edition. The newly released MK7 GTI and the 'new' WRX STI...but neither made it to the finalists round. Crazy to believe this was 3 whole years ago....

Anyway, 3rd place for the CTR over the Lexus was a surprise since a lot of the auto journo world seems to be in love with it. I'm just happy that our hot rodded family hatchback is even in the conversation with any of the other entries here...seriously the price and power difference is huge yet this car is still more 'desirable' to drive hard+on the daily vs a Quadrifoglio or a TTRS...what a time to be an enthusiast...
 
Last edited:

DevonK

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2017
Threads
12
Messages
270
Reaction score
121
Location
Toronto
Vehicle(s)
TBD
Country flag
The R&T guys clearly thought highly of the CTR, but it did not really rank third in this shootout in any meaningful way - remember the cars first competed within a small class, and then the class winners were ranked.

If a boxing tournament had four weight divisions, and you then ranked the 4 divisional winners in the same way as was done in this shootout, nobody could reasonably claim that the winner of say the flyweight division was a better boxer in any absolute sense than the guy who came second in the heavyweight division; the flyweight would not likely last a round against the heavyweight.

If the CTR had competed directly against say the AMG GT R or the 911 GT3. does anyone seriously think it would have been the editors' preference? Of course one can argue that such a comparison is rather beside the point given the pricing differentials, but that is a separate consideration.
 

warrendeath

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Threads
16
Messages
404
Reaction score
198
Location
Cincinnati, Ohio
Vehicle(s)
2017 Honda Civic Type-R 'Hellbat'
Like I said before, any list in performance vehicle where the Type R is even LISTED is a HUGE deal considering A, price point and B, the set up(FWD).

To be thought of THIS highly is absolutely insane.
 

mathewp

Senior Member
First Name
Mathew
Joined
Aug 25, 2017
Threads
3
Messages
101
Reaction score
55
Location
MA
Vehicle(s)
CW Civic Type R, Jeep Wrangler
Country flag
Looking at the methodology R&T used, CTR beat Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio, Audi TT RS in the wildcard category and then beat Lexus LC500 (winner of the grand tourer category) in the final thereby beating Bentley Continental Supersports which had lost to Lexus LC500. So even if all remaining cars beat CTR in this evaluation, it will still finish 6th which is a decent accomplishment because all other cars are at least twice as expensive as CTR.
 

bubbaleenc

Owning the country roads.
Joined
Jul 26, 2016
Threads
3
Messages
121
Reaction score
144
Location
North Carolina
Vehicle(s)
'16 EX-T Sedan '01 4Runner '18 Suburban
Country flag
This once again highlights my observation of the CTR:

The CTR is a really hot model who dresses a bit on the tacky side but is still relatively low-maintenance. It wears you out something awesome, never leaves you wanting for much and is always ready to take you on another hot and wild ride. You still notice the other models, but you doubt that the grass is really any greener on the other side of the fence.
 


UFO CTR

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2016
Threads
22
Messages
2,530
Reaction score
1,877
Location
San Frrancisco, CA
Vehicle(s)
2017 CTR#1348
Country flag
Maybe, but not as much hype as when it set the 'ring record.
Yes, but this is"real world" comparisons...I'm actually more hype about this than the 'ring record. Still, as soon as we took deliveries of our CTRs, we knew they were special even after only the first miles. Now this article just proved it! :)
 

DevonK

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2017
Threads
12
Messages
270
Reaction score
121
Location
Toronto
Vehicle(s)
TBD
Country flag
Looking at the methodology R&T used, CTR beat Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio, Audi TT RS in the wildcard category and then beat Lexus LC500 (winner of the grand tourer category) in the final thereby beating Bentley Continental Supersports which had lost to Lexus LC500. So even if all remaining cars beat CTR in this evaluation, it will still finish 6th which is a decent accomplishment because all other cars are at least twice as expensive as CTR.
Good points - the CTR besting such a capable car as the TT RS in a direct comparison is truly impressive. But this being a performance car of the year shootout, its beating luxo GTs like the Lexus and Bentley which prioritize comfortable cruising over sharp handling is perhaps not so surprising.
 

jakdotdot

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2017
Threads
13
Messages
862
Reaction score
721
Location
Cali
Vehicle(s)
2018 SI
Country flag
Good points - the CTR besting such a capable car as the TT RS in a direct comparison is truly impressive. But this being a performance car of the year shootout, its beating luxo GTs like the Lexus and Bentley which prioritize comfortable cruising over sharp handling is perhaps not so surprising.
Hard to say how impressive it is from how little information they have provided in the online article.
 

DevonK

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2017
Threads
12
Messages
270
Reaction score
121
Location
Toronto
Vehicle(s)
TBD
Country flag
Well there will be more in the published article, or course - the web content is just a teaser for the magazine.

Still, the writers said enough to make it clear they found the TT RS to be a considerably more boring drive than the CTR. When you take into account the relative cost of the two cars, and the fact that Audi has been labouring for many years to turn the TT S and TT RS into true sportscars, I'd say Honda's accomplishment was impressive. Not perfect though - they do complain a bit about inert steering, and a "wheezy" engine note.
Sponsored

 


 


Top